A Companion to European Union Law and International Law

 

Edited by

Dennis Patterson and Anna Södersten

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Contributors

Ari Afilalo is professor of law at Rutgers University School of Law.

Anthony Arnull is Barber Professor of Jurisprudence at University of Birmingham.

Loïc Azoulai is professor of European law at the European University Institute.

Catherine Barnard is professor of European Union law at the University of Cambridge.

Frank S. Benyon is the former principal legal advisor to the European Commission. He is now a senior fellow in the Department of Law of the European University Institute.

Roland Bieber is professor emeritus, former Jean Monnet Chair of European Law, former vice dean, University of Lausanne, and former legal advisor, European Parliament.

Andrea Biondi is professor of European Union law at King’s College London.

Djemila Carron is a PhD candidate at the University of Geneva.

Roger S. Clark is Board of Governors Professor at Rutgers University.

Paul Craig is professor of English law at the University of Oxford.

Marise Cremona is professor of European law at the European University Institute.

Deirdre Curtin is professor of European Law at the University of Amsterdam and director of the Amsterdam Center of European Law and Governance.

Mark Dawson is professor of European law and governance at the Hertie School of Governance.

Pedro Caro de Sousa is a lecturer at the University of Reading.

Bruno de Witte is professor of European Union law at the European University Institute.

Michael Dougan is professor of European law and Jean Monnet Chair in EU Law at the University of Liverpool.

Sionaidh Douglas-Scott is professor of European and human rights law at the University of Oxford.

John Erik Fossum is professor at the ARENA Centre for European Studies, Oslo.

Elspeth Guild is Jean Monnet Professor ad personam at Queen Mary, University of London and at the Radboud University Nijmegen.

Christian Joerges is a research professor at the University of Bremen and co-director of the Center for European Law and Politics and part-time senior professor for law and society at the Hertie School of Governance in Berlin. He was formerly professor of economic law at the European University Institute.

Jan Klabbers is Martti Ahtisaari Academy Professor at the University of Helsinki.

Maria Lee is professor of law at University College London.

Miguel Poiares Maduro is former director of the Global Governance Program, professor of law at the European University Institute, and Portuguese minister for regional development.

Ravi Mehta is an English barrister practicing at Blackstone Chambers and specializing in European and international law.

Hans-Wolfgang Micklitz is professor of economic law at the European University Institute.

Valsamis Mitsilegas is professor of European criminal law at Queen Mary University of London.

Giorgio Monti is professor of competition law at the European University Institute.

Dennis Patterson is Board of Governors Professor of Law and Philosophy, Rutgers University. chair in legal philosophy and legal theory, European University Institute, chair in jurisprudence and international trade at Swansea University.

Steve Peers is a professor at the University of Essex.

Zane Rasnača is a PhD researcher at the European University Institute.

Allan Rosas is a judge of the Court of Justice of the European Union.

Marco Sassòli is professor of international law at the University of Geneva.

Martin Scheinin is professor of international law and human rights at the European University Institute.

Silvana Sciarra is a judge of the Constitutional Court of Italy.

Sideek M. Seyad is an associate professor at Stockholm University

Piet Jan Slot is professor of European and economic law at the University of Leiden.

Anna Södersten is a lecturer in law at Uppsala University.

Bariş Soyer is professor of law at Swansea University.

Joel P. Trachtman is professor of international law at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, Tufts University.

Stephen Weatherill is the Jacques Delors Professor of European Law at the University of Oxford.

Ramses A. Wessel is professor of international and European institutional law at the University of Twente.

Katja S. Ziegler is Sir Robert Jennings Professor of International Law at the University of Leicester.

Preface

The essays in this book cover current topics in European Union law and international law. Why a book on both EU law and international law? The European Union is sometimes described as an international organization created by its member states under an international treaty. Under this view, it is the pacta sunt servanda formula that explains the source of authority of the Union. However, in the 1960s, the European Court of Justice declared that the European Union was properly conceived as a “new legal order” and, years later, that the EU treaties were a “Constitutional Charter.” This evolution suggests that the European Union cannot be understood as a traditional international organization. Although the nature of the Union has not been completely settled, the EU treaties clearly go beyond classic international treaties.

Moreover, EU law and international law undeniably have many points of contact. There is a fair amount of EU legislation that implements (or in other ways is derived from) international law. Further, the European Union is an important actor on the international scene: it takes an active role in the creation and shaping of international law. We believe that one needs to understand international law – or at least have some knowledge of international law – in order to understand EU law.

The central feature of this book is its integration of these fields. While the central focus is the law of the European Union, the international law entries complement and enhance the reader’s understanding of EU law. However, this book is not merely about pointing out similarities between these fields; it is equally about pointing out differences. To this end, we have asked the authors – to the extent that it is possible, and where appropriate – to integrate the two areas of law. For some of the topics, we thought it would be more fruitful to have two separate entries: one entry that deals specifically with the EU law aspects of a specific topic and another entry that deals with the international law aspects.

Much has happened since we began working on this book. The effects of the economic and financial crisis (which in Europe turned into a “Eurocrisis”) are still felt. The crisis had profound effects on both the EU member states and the European Union. Consequently, many entries include some analysis of the crisis and its effects on law. As we edited this book, there was an occasional sense that little could be expected for the future of European integration.

At the same time, the “dust” from the Lisbon Treaty started to settle. The Lisbon Treaty, which amends the European Union’s core treaties, entered into force in 2009. It marked the end of a decade of discussions among the EU member states about how to reform the Union. Legal scholars will continue to analyze the legal implications of the Lisbon Treaty for many years to come; a considerable number of the entries in this volume devote space to these aspects.

The Companion is divided into six parts: (I) International Law and EU Law; (II) EU Political Institutions and Decision Making; (III) The Court; (IV) Economic Dimensions of the European Union; (V) The European Union and the External World; (VI) Human Rights, Social Issues, and the Environment. Many entries have overlapping themes; they could fit into more than one part. However, we believe that this arrangement of the entries will facilitate the reader’s use of the book. Each part presents a multitude of topics and perspectives to a relatively coherent theme.

We have assembled some of the best scholars in these fields. We asked the authors to survey the topic assigned and, where appropriate, indicate their own view of the questions and issues at stake. The entries cover the key figures, terms, topics, and problems in the field. The collection of the entries took much longer than expected but it was certainly worth the effort; the book displays a diversity, range, and richness of legal scholarship. We wish to thank the authors who have contributed their time and talent to this Companion. Many of the entries are remarkable in terms of originality and presentation. We are grateful to Bosko Tripkovic and Sofie Christine Møller for their editorial assistance in preparing this book for publication. We are especially grateful to Felicity Marsh for copy editing that went beyond our expectations. We cannot be emphatic enough in our appreciation for her work on this project.

The Companion could serve as a reference work, but it is much more than that; it offers commentaries on the work pursued in each field. It is our hope that the entries are of interest to both beginning students and professionals.

Abbreviations

ATTArms Trade Treaty
BATbest available techniques
BITsbilateral investment agreements
BREFsBAT reference notes
CCPCommon Commercial Policy
CEASCommon European Asylum System
CESLCommon European Sales Law
CERDConvention for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination
CFSPCommon Foreign and Security Policy
CFICourt of First Instance
CFRCommon Frame of Reference
CILcustomary international law
CJEUCourt of Justice of the European Union
COREPERComité des représentants permanents (Committee of permanent representatives of the member states)
CRCConvention on the Rights of the Child
CRPDConvention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
CSDPCommon Security and Defence Policy
CTConstitutional Treaty
DCFRDraft of a Common Frame of Reference
DSBDispute Settlement Body
EAWEuropean Arrest Warrant
ECEuropean Community
EC TreatyTreaty establishing the European Community
ECBEuropean Central Bank
ECHREuropean Convention on Human Rights
ECJEuropean Court of Justice
ECSEuropean Committee for Standardization
ECSCEuropean Coal and Steel Community
ECtHREuropean Court of Human Rights
EDCEuropean Defence Community
EEASEuropean External Action Service
EEBEuropean Environmental Bureau
EECEuropean Economic Community
EEC TreatyTreaty establishing the European Economic Community
EEZExclusive Economic Zones
EFSFEuropean Financial Stability Facility
EFSMEuropean Financial Stabilization Mechanism
ELVsemission limit values
EMASEco-Management and Audit Scheme
EMUEconomic and Monetary Union
EPEuropean Parliament
EPCEuropean Political Community
EPPOEuropean Public Prosecutor’s Office
EQSsenvironmental quality standards
ESCBEuropean System of Central Banks
ESMEuropean Stability Mechanism
ETUCEuropean Trade Union Confederation
EUEuropean Union
EuratomEuropean Atomic Energy Community
GATSGeneral Agreement on Trade in Services
GATTGeneral Agreement on Tariffs and Trade
GBERGeneral Block Exemption Regulation
GCGeneral Court
GDPGross Domestic Product
GSP+sustainable development and good governance
ICCInternational Criminal Court
ICCPRInternational Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
ICESCRInternational Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
ICNInternational Competition Network
ICJInternational Court of Justice
IEDIndustrial Emissions Directive
IGCIntergovernmental Conference
IHFFCInternational Humanitarian Fact-Finding Commission
IHLInternational Humanitarian Law
IMFInternational Monetary Fund
IOMInternational Organization for Migration
IPPCIntegrated Pollution Prevention and Control
MARPOLInternational Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships
MiFIDMarkets in Financial Instruments Directive
MiFIRMarkets in Financial Instruments Regulation
NATONorth Atlantic Treaty Organization
NGONon-Governmental Organization
NIACnon-international armed conflict
OASOrganization of American States
OECDOrganisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
OICOrganization of the Islamic Conference
OLAFEuropean Anti-Fraud Office
OMCOpen Method of Coordination
OPECOrganization of Petroleum Exporting Countries
OSCEOrganization for Security and Co-operation in Europe
PCIJPermanent Court of International Justice
PSCPolitical and Security Committee
SEASingle European Act
SISSchengen Information System
TATreaty of Amsterdam
TEUTreaty on European Union
TFEUTreaty on the Functioning of the European Union
TLTreaty of Lisbon
TSCGTreaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance in the Economic and Monetary Union
TWGTechnical Working Group
UNUnited Nations
UDHRUniversal Declaration of Human Rights
UNCLOSUnited Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea
UNCTADUnited Nations Conference on Trade and Development
UNECEUnited Nations Economic Commission for Europe
VCLTVienna Convention on the Law of Treaties
VISVisa Information System
WHOWorld Health Organization
WTOWorld Trade Organization

Part I
International Law and EU Law